smartphone cameras

Q&A: Limitations of smartphone cameras (ii)

/ spqr / Leave a comment

The remainder of the Q&A.

Is battery life a big issue?

Smartphones have an extremely limited battery life. The newer smartphones like the iPhone have exceptional battery life, for a phone, but not for a camera. Batteries just don’t last that long with smartphones, requiring a battery pack of some sort to keep them going. It is hard to pin down exactly how many photos you can take off a charge, because a smartphone is not a dedicated camera, and therefore uses power for things apart from taking photos. For average use, smartphone batteries are more than adequate, however when used when travelling it could become an issue, largely due to the number of photographs taken. It is easy to have multiple spare batteries for a camera.

Are smartphones limited by storage?

Smartphones differ on whether they just offer on-board storage (Apple) or offer access to a removable microSD card slot (Android). Choosing a smartphone with no expandable storage means things will fill up very quickly.

Are smartphones easy to use as cameras?

Smartphones tend to lack what I like to call tactile awareness. They aren’t really that ergonomic from the point of holding them, let alone using features. There are some apps that allow better creative control, but all have to be manipulated by means of the touchscreen. And even then they have somewhat poor creative control. Although cameras often suffer from poorly designed menus, the problem with smartphones is that even the best photography software suffers from having a lot of features in a small space. This is sometimes balanced by the amount of post-processing techniques available, but editing a photograph on a small screen is severely limiting. Sure, these smartphones do have fancy AI software to reduce issues, and make “nice” looking photographs, but there is one inherent limitation with this – a loss of character. Smartphone displays, however good aren’t really ideal for photography. Sometimes its hard to see what you are shooting due to glare. Cameras have an EVF which is shielded from the sun.

Can smartphones produce the same aesthetics?

Aesthetics on a camera is really down to the quality and type of lenses. Most cameras, except for compacts, have interchangeable lenses which makes it easier to achieve a certain aesthetic. For example smartphone cameras can generally not produce bokeh naturally. Smartphone cameras are not exactly designed to have narrow depth-of-field areas, without which it is impossible to naturally create bokeh. Bokeh is typically found in portrait-style photographs where it is added algorithmically by means of computational photography and machine learning (it basically delineates a subject, and then artificially adds blur to the background).

What things do DSLR/mirrorless cameras do better?

  1. Real cameras have larger sensors. Larger sensors mean better quality images.
  2. Real cameras have better lenses – high quality optical glass, and faster apertures.
  3. Real cameras offer more control – shutter speed, ISO, aperture
  4. Real cameras shoot in RAW
  5. Real cameras are dedicated to one job, and last longer.

Can smartphone cameras handle climate extremes?

This is a important, because smartphones use Lithium-Ion batteries which are effected by temperature extremes. For example Apple suggests keeping their devices between zero and 35°C. Cold batteries can slow down the function of a smartphone. Cameras on the other hand have a broader working range of temperatures, from 0 to 40°C, and some are designed for temperatures as low as -10°C (e.g. Fujifilm X-T4). Smartphone batteries are also not removable, versus camera batteries which can be removed and kept warm while they are not being used in the cold. Smartphones and freezing temperatures do not mix well. Professional cameras can shoot through everything.

Are smartphone zoom lenses useful?

Smartphones can have either digital or optical zoom, or both. Optical zoom provides high-quality, lossless magnification. Digital zoom however enlarges the captured image, and does not involve movement of the camera lens. Digital zoom just zooms in on the pixels, and may result in a loss of image quality. It is achieved by magnifying and interpolating pixels, which can lead to a loss of sharpness and detail. When used on smartphones, digital zoom is often used when the physical limitations of the lens prevent further optical zoom. Some, like the plain iPhone 14, only have digital zoom (5× in this case). The main pros of digital zoom are related to smartphone form-factor: convenience, compact design and cost effectiveness. But the cons somewhat outweigh the pros: loss of image quality, no true magnification, interpolation artifacts, and inferior performance in low light.

Q&A: Limitations of smartphone cameras (i)

/ spqr

Here I’m going to explain a bit more about the caveats of smartphone cameras in the form of a FAQ. I will add that for all their compactness, smartphone cameras produce incredible images, they just have the same limitations all small devices have.

Is the image quality as good as a dedicated digital camera?

Image quality is partially reliant on the size of photosites, the building blocks of digital images. The larger the photosite, the better it is for low-light conditions. Smartphones have relatively small sensors, and therefore are constrained by the size of their photosites. They still produce images with exceptional quality, but there is a reason people choose full-frame and medium sized sensors for professional work.

Regardless of what companies say, image quality on a smartphone will never be as good as those on a camera. The iPhone 14 Pro has a 1/1.28” sensor on the wide camera with a sensor area of 75mm2, and a pixel pitch of 1.22μm in 48MP mode (2.44μm in 12MP mode). Don’t get me wrong, the technology is amazing – squeezing a camera with a 7-element, 24mm focal length equivalent lens with optical sensor shift. But those pixels are small, and there is only so far you can scale up a 12MP image. In comparison, a 26MP APS-C camera sensor has photosites that have nearly four times the area of the 14 Pro, which means more light can be captured. It also has twice the number of photosites, more photosites amounts to better resolution.

Are lens elements made of plastic?

Cameras are all about the glass, or in the case of smartphones – plastic. Most smartphone cameras are comprised of lens elements made out of injection molded optical plastic. Now plastic lenses have been around for a long while, and they have benefits and drawbacks. There are many reasons for this, most notably the fact that plastic elements can be molded into much more extreme aspheric shapes, something not possible in optical glass (aspherical lenses are used in high-end optics to create sharper images and reduce or eliminate some types of optical imperfections). Plastic also allows for thinner lenses that have more complex flange geometries.

An example of a plastic 5-element smartphone lens.Made of injection-molded optical plastic, they are extremely cheap to produce.

Are lens apertures limited?

The aperture of a lens controls how much light makes its way through to the sensor, controlling things like depth-of-field (or how much of the scene is in focus). Smartphones that work well in low-light situations, without the use of a flash, have large apertures. The wide lens on the iPhone 14 Pro has an aperture of f/1.78, which allows for good low-light performance, but taken into context, an aperture of f/1.78 has the DOF equivalent of an f/6.1 aperture on a full-frame camera. That makes it hard to produce blurry effects naturally – they are usually added artificially in post-processing. These lenses are stuck with a single fixed aperture, providing limited control of exposure. It may seem like you can change the aperture, but apps that allow the aperture to be changed to increase the amount of background blur are really just adding a certain amount of artificial background blur. Camera lenses can change the aperture, and hence the depth of field, facilitating natural blur, i.e. bokeh.

Do smartphones create natural Bokeh?

Bokeh has to do with unfocused regions in an image, and relies heavily on a shallow depth-of-field. Many smartphones use wide-angle lenses, and as a result, have quite a large depth-of-field (DOF), the distance between the nearest and farthest elements in a scene that are in acceptably sharp focus. The available depth of field increases as the sensor size and lens focal length decrease, which is why smartphone photographs tend to have very large DOFs. Landscapes, everyday shots, even close-ups have very little out-of-focus. How is bokeh created? Through the power of algorithms. The iPhone uses both cameras to create a DOF-effect in Portrait Mode. It combines the photographs taken by the wide-angle and telephoto lenses, and after applying some computational magic, produces a blurred background. There is even a Depth Control feature which allows the bokeh, to be tailored, between an aperture of f/1.4 and f/16. But it is computationally created, and bokeh is a natural phenomena which occurs in part because of lens optics.

Are different lens focal lengths useful?

While these lenses are exceptionally designed for the small space they are required to inhabit, they can not really be compared to the larger glass available in dedicated cameras. Photography is about light, and smartphone lenses are extremely small and so don’t really let in the same amount of light. The 24mm equivalent wide angle lens of the iPhone 14 Pro has an actual focal length of 6.9mm (35mm equivalent), the 13mm is actually only 2.2mm, and the 77mm is only 9mm. Basically the focal lengths often used to described in lenses are in terms of their 35mm equivalents, likely to create better associations. For example a 77mm telephoto lens seems easier to understand than a 9mm telephoto.

To get a bit technical, this means the effective diameter of the entrance pupil (DEP) of the wide-angle 6.9mm lens with a max aperture of f/1.78 is 6.9/1.78 = 3.88mm. Comparing this to the equivalent 24mm full-frame lens, say the Sony FE 24mm f/1.4, and the DEP is 17.14mm, much larger. More area equals more light. Apart from the fixed aperture, and compactness of the lenses, there is another big issue. Smartphone lenses, regardless of how many of them are on a phone, can only cover a finite number of focal lengths. Cameras, especially those with interchangeable lenses, can use optical zoom lenses that cover a very broad range of focal lengths. For example the APS-C lens Fujifilm XF 18-135mm (f/3.5-5.6) covers the full-frame equivalent of 36 to 270mm.